Search Indiana Death Records

•  Indiana Newspapers, Full Search (1804-1992), 150 titles
•  Indiana Obituary Search, (1988-current)
•  Indiana Funeral Notices

Click photo to enlarge

Click photo to enlarge

Nutter Cemetery
Martinsville, Morgan County, Indiana

Lat: 39° 27' 48"N, Lon: 86° 25' 23"W
Washington Twp, Sec 21

Contributed by Jeff Curtis, Aug 25, 2006, lst edited Aug 29, 2006 [jefftcurtis@earthlink.net]. Total records = 191.

To reach this cemetery from Martinsville, drive north on Blue Bluff Road for about 2.5 miles. Turn right onto an unnamed road that leads back to the cemetery, which is just south of the lake. The dam of the lake is clearly visible from Blue Bluff Road.

This cemetery is well cared for, and the condition of the headstones seems to be quite good. The cemetery was already inactive in 1967. Have not found when it was established and who maintains it.

I have transcribed, with permission, from work completed in Sep of 1967 by Carl and Janet Cowen, when they read all existing and legible stones.

- Jeff Curtis

Asher, Emil A, b. 1915, d. 1946
Ballinger, Laura A. Reynolds, b. 21 Nov 1901, d. 22 Aug 1958, s/w William Ballinger
Ballinger, William Bradley, b. 8 Feb 1894, d. 5 Nov 1930
Ballinger, William, b. 1894, d. 13 Apr 1905, temporary stone
Baughn, Albert T, b. 7 Apr 1925, d. 8 Jan 1945, Pfc died for his country
Baughn, Elmer, b. 1886, d. 1949
Baughn, Jean, b. 1927, d. 19 May 1905
Baughn, Jose Ann, b. 1886, d. 1940, s/w Elmer Baughn, and temporary marker
Buckner, Martha, d. 15 Nov 1867, age: 54y 3m 12d, wife of Jehu
Burge, Ada S, b. 1887, d. 1917
Burke, James Harvey, b. 1877, d. 1956
Burke, Jeanette, b. 30 Oct 1875, d. 9 Feb 1939, wife of James H Burke
Burns, Emma Bell Ward, b. 1870, d. 1899, wife of Harry H Burns
Burpo, Clide O, b. 1880, d. 1965, s/w Frederick Burpo
Burpo, Frederick L, b. 1871, d. 1934, also temporary marker
Cain, Stella May, d. 16 Nov 1885, age: 1y 3m, daughter of J.D. and S.A. Cain
Cambell, Mary E, b. 28 Jul 1860, d. 17 Nov 1864, daughter of W and H Campbell
Campbell, Hannah, b. 6 Jul 1836, d. 25 Oct 1897
Campbell, William, b. 10 Jun 1831, d. 24 Nov 1921
Campbell, William, b. 23 Jan 1844, d. 23 Jan 1862, Father
Cobb, Annettie, b. 20 Mar 1859, d. 16 Mar 1888, age: 28y 11m 26d, Wife of J.N. Cobb
Cobb, Everett R, b. 20 Aug 1885, d. 4 Aug 1889, Son of John N and Annettie Cobb
Cobb, Harriett A, b. 10 Aug 1842, d. 21 Oct 1860, age: 18y 2m 11d, Wife of Van B Cobb, Daughter of Sarah and John Nutter, s/w Albert Nutter, 2 stones
Craig, Clarinda, d. 3 Aug 1860, age: 12y 1m 24d, daughter of W.H. and I Craig
Craig, Isabelle, d. 1 Sep 1881, age: 71y 3m 10d, wife of Wm H Craig
Craig, Wm H., d. 27 Jun 1863, age: 63y 1m 9d
Creed, Area A, b. 1881, d. 1881, daughters of T.V. and C.J. Creed, two small footstones and one headstone
Creed, Cynthia J, b. 1855, d. 1930
Creed, Thomas V, b. 1854, d. 1917
Culmer, Bruce N, b. 1890, d. 1918, son of W.W. and M.J. Culmer
Culmer, Genevieve, b. 1903, d. 1915, Daughter of W.W. and M.J. Culmer
Culmer, William W, b. 1863, d. 1939
Davis, Mary, no dates, Grandmother
Duckworth, Cora, d. 30 Aug 1866, age: 5m 20d, daughter of J.A.J. and H Duckworth
Duncan, David A, b. 21 Jan 1841, d. 20 Apr 1872
Duncan, Luella J, d. 6 Nov 1874, age: 14y 6m, daugher of Jacob W. and Mary A Duncan
Duncan, infant, d. 20 Mar 1869, infant of W and M Duncan
Dunigan, James Henry, b. 1859, d. 1921
Dunigan, Jenny, b. 1855, d. 1920
Eggers, Robert I, b. 17 Mar 13, d. 9 Dec 1916
Eudaly, Ann, d. 10 Jan 1874, age: 23y 5m 25d, wife of J.E. Eudaly
Farrand, James W, b. 1859, d. 24 Feb 1936, 2 stones
Ferguson, Carrie A, b. 1843, d. 1884, wife of Jessie Ferguson, Mother
Fulkerson, Sarah B, b. 7 May 1825, d. 24 Mar 1894
Fulkerson, Wm L, b. 13 Oct 1824, d., IOOF symbol
Garrett, Lucinda, no dates
Garrett, Nancy, d. 11 Nov 1888, age: 68y 2m 9d, wife of John W
Goins, Gus, b. 1866, d. 1958
Gray, Arlo Thomas, b. 21 Jul 1910, d. 11 Sep 1957, Ind Pvt Deml WW II
Gray, James H, b. 1876, d. 1943
Griffith, Louis J, b. 1833, d. 1927
Hammon, Mary F, b. 1859, d. 1943, large stone on plot has Pryor on one side and Hammon on the other
Harn, Thurza Phelps, b. 1868, d. 1943
Harris, William F, b. 1842, d. 1926
Harris, Zuralda, d. 7 Nov 1884, age: 35y 3m 21d, wife of W.F. Harris and daughter of F.P.A and E.E. Phelps
Harrison, Mary, b. 2 Jun 1832, d. 2 Jun 1863, Wife of William R and Daughter of Joel and Mary Wilson
Hastings, Charlie, d. 15 Aug 1884, age: 10y 7m 7d, son of E.J. and M. Hastings
Hastings, Francis, b. 18 Dec 1819, d. 27 Jul 1866, wife of Isaac Hastings
Hastings, Isaac, d. 20 Jan 1876, age: 60y 7m 9d
Hastings, Malinda, d. 11 Oct 1891, age: 56y 11d, wife of Isaac Hastings, s/w Isaac Hastings
Hastings, Nancy, no dates
Hatfield, Anna B, b. 21 Jun 1860, d. 18 Oct 45
Hendricks, Bess Aleen, b. 1883, d. 1918, s/w Walter Hendricks
Hendricks, Charlotte T, b. 29 Aug 1858, d. 25 Jun 1927, s/w Thompson Hendricks
Hendricks, Edward, b. 5 Apr 1850, d. 4 Jul 1896, s/w Thompson Hendricks
Hendricks, Emily J, b. 20 Aug 1845, d. 19 May 1924, s/w Thompson Hendricks
Hendricks, Evangeline Hastings, b. 1858, d. 1930, his Wife, s/w Walter Hendricks
Hendricks, Horace, b. 23 Aug 1847, d. 3 Dec 1864, s/w Thompson Hendricks
Hendricks, Mary Eloise, b. 1880, d. 19??, s/w Walter Hendricks
Hendricks, Mary F, b. 6 Jan 1856, d. 1 Apr 1933, s/w Thompson Hendricks
Hendricks, Mary J, b. 18 Oct 1824, d. 17 Jul 1905, s/w Thompson Hendricks
Hendricks, Otis H, b. 1 Mar 1865, d. 18 May 1876, s/w Thompson Hendricks
Hendricks, Robert A, b. 24 Apr 1881, d. 8 Feb 1883, s/w Thompson Hendricks
Hendricks, Sarah J, b. 22 Jul 1856, d. 20 Sep 1886
Hendricks, T Anderson, b. 1887, d. 19??, s/w Walter Hendricks
Hendricks, Thompson, b. 9 Feb 1814, d. 14 Aug 1881
Hendricks, Venus T, b. 19 Nov 1868, d. 25 Dec 1870, s/w Thompson Hendricks
Hendricks, Walter E (M.D.), b. 16 Nov 1852, d. 1 Aug 1942, s/w Thompson Hendricks, 2 stones
Hendricks, Zuriah J, b. 22 Aug 1878, d. 31 Mar 1879
Johnson, Isaac S, b. 28 May 1828, d. 30 Jan 1901
Johnson, Susan, b. 5 Dec 1829, d. 7 Mar 1899, Mother, s/w Isaac S Johnson
Kelly, William H, b. 1889, d. 1935
Kirkland, James, d. 16 Aug 1866, age: 67y 16d
Lafary, Perlina, d. 27 Jun 1887, age: 51y 3m 22d, Wife of A.J. Lafary
Ledbetter, Nellie, b. 1872, d. 9 May 1905
Ledbetter, Sidney, b. 1859, d. 21 Apr 1905
Lewis, Anna May, b. 31 May 02, d., their daughter, s/w Silvanis Lewis
Lewis, Harriet A Sweet, b. 13 Feb 1868, d. 29 Feb 1908, his wife, s/w Silvanis Lewis
Lewis, Silvanis, b. 25 Mar 1859, d. no date
Magenis, Emma, b. 26 Aug 1865, d. 11 Sep 1865, daughter of T. and M. Magenis
Major, Mary Eleanor, b. 1856, d. 1933
Major, Sylvanus, b. 1849, d. 1914
Major, Z Iris, b. 1875, d. 1946
Mann, James K, b. 1872, d. 1945
Mann, K K, d., Co M 18th Ky Inf, Military stone
Mann, William M, b. 1858, d. 1932
Matthews, Mattie E, d. 15 Aug 1864, age: 1y 5m 23d, duaghter of M. and P.L. Matthews
Matthews, infant, no dates, daugher of Bess and Willard Matthews
McCormick, Elizabeth J, b. 15 May 1818, d., Wife of William
McCormick, William, b. 20 Jul 1841, d. 16 Mar 1886, s/w Elizabeth McCormick
McCoy, Sarah C., d. 2 Jan 1861, age: 16y 7m, daughter of P.B. and A.M. McCoy
McGinnis, Mary E, b. 1834, d. 1898
McGinnis, Thomas, b. 1835, d. 1920, Co F 27th Ind Inf, Military stone
Milton, J. W., no dates
Monce, Julia G, b. 1868, d. 1945
Monce, Oscar O, b. 1870, d. 1940
Moody, Charles M, d. 16 Feb 1935, Alabama Sqt 11 Inf 5th Div, Military stone
Morrison, Logan, d. 16 Sep 1837, age: 1y 3m 14d, son of J and K Morisson
Myers, Betty Jane, d. 1925, infant
Neal, David Eugene, d. 1952
Neal, James Henry, b. 1893, d. 1926
Neal, Mary Barger, b. 1893, d. 1929
Neal, Nancy J, b. 22 Feb 1867, d., his wife
Neal, Samuel O, b. 1880, d. 1942
Neal, Susie A, b. 1888, d. 1932
Neal, Sylvia E, b. 1909, d. 1927
Nutter, Albert H, b. 2 May 1854, d. 22 Jan 1896
Nutter, Albert H, b. 28 Dec 1888, d. 2 Mar 1912, s/w Albert Nutter
Nutter, Clement H, d. 24 Dec 1889, age: 69y 17d
Nutter, D. C., b. 23 Feb 1823, d. 4 Sep 1895
Nutter, Edith E, b. 7 Oct 1881, d. 18 Aug 1959, s/w Albert Nutter
Nutter, Emily J, b. 20 Aug 1845, d. 19 May 1924, his Wife
Nutter, Emma, d. 31 Jan 1856, age: 1y 4m 2d
Nutter, Huitt H, no dates
Nutter, Isaac W, b. 2 Dec 1839, d. 27 May 1936
Nutter, John T, b. 28 Feb 1867, d. 12 Dec 1867
Nutter, John, b. 9 Aug 1817, d. 11 Aug 1892, s/w Albert Nutter
Nutter, Julia, d. 13 Feb 1867, age: 36y
Nutter, Karl I, b. 7 Apr 1873, d.
Nutter, Lottie T, b. 29 Aug 1858, d. 25 Jun 1927, Wife of Albert H Nutter, s/w Albert Nutter
Nutter, Mary J, b. 17 Sep 1870, d. 1 Jan 1909, Mother
Nutter, Maudie B, d. 10 Jun 1887, age: 7m 14d, Daugher of C.B. and E.E. Nutter
Nutter, Sarah, b. 19 Dec 1822, d. 16 Nov 1897, s/w Albert Nutter
Nutter, William C, b. 7 Sep 1876, d. 14 Jan 1919, s/w Albert Nutter
Nutter, William H, d. 13 Sep 1867, age: 7m 18d, son of C and J.W. Nutter
Nutter, infant, d. 13 Jul 1860, Son of Sarah and John Nutter, s/w Albert Nutter
Nutter, infant, d. 1890, son of H.H. and C.D. Nutter
Patton, Charles Davis, d., stepson of H. Nutter
Payton, Elizabeth, b. 17 Jan 1845, d. 20 Jan 1872, his wife, s/w Thompson Payton
Payton, Sarah, b. 1869, d. 1872, daughter of T and E.J. Payton, sw/ Thompson Payton
Payton, Thompson, d. 1872, Co C 33 Ind Inf, Military Stone
Phelps, Francis Philo A, II, b. 1859, d. 1932
Phelps, Allen H, b. 1857, d. 1931
Phelps, Celestina, b. 1824, d. 1912
Phelps, Edward T, d. 15 Aug 1880, age: 54y 2m 23d
Phelps, Eleanor E, b. 15 Oct 1827, d. 4 May 1898, Mother, s/w Tull Phelps
Phelps, Francis P. A., b. 4 Dec 1822, d. 22 Feb 1895, Father, s/w Tull Phelps
Phelps, George A, d. 23 Feb 1833, age: 36y 3m 25d
Phelps, Harry, b. 1888, d. 1909, son of A. H. and K. Phelps
Phelps, Rebecca, d. 25 Feb 1863, age: 72y 5m, Wife of G.A. Phelps
Phelps, Sine E, b. 6 Feb 1856, d. 28 Mar 1922, s/w Tull Phelps
Phelps, Tull, b. 26 Jan 1851, d. 28 Jan 1933
Poppino, George H, b. 8 Feb 1899, d. 20 Mar 47, Ind Pfc 22 Inf WW I
Pryor, Hattie Ann, b. 1875, d. 1925
Robertson, Wm, d., Co E 3 Ind Mex War, Military stone
Seaman, Eva M, d. 19 Apr 1892, age: 21y 5m 12d, wife of J.W. Seaman
Seaman, Jane, d. 18 Nov 1883, age: 74y 4m 11d, wife of Joseph Seaman
Seitz, Nettie, d. 18 Aug 1897, age: 1y 18d, daughter of C.A. and M.D. Seitz
Shane, Minor, b. 1913, d. 1913
Sparks, Morton Ellsworth, b. 29 Sep 1862, d. 16 Aug 1865, son of W.J. and H.A. Sparks
Sparks, infant, d. 25 Aug 1867, daughter of W.J. and H.A. Sparks
Sweet, Anna, d. 25 Oct 1877, age: 7y 8m 25d, daughter of A and H Sweet
Sweet, Austin, b. 16 Aug 1831, d. 18 Aug 1903
Sweet, Benjamin F, b. 1856, d. 1944
Sweet, Benjamin, d. 17 Nov 1862, age: 63y 1m 26d
Sweet, Halleck C, b. 8 Feb 1862, d. 9 Aug 1864, son of A and H.K. Sweet
Sweet, Keziah H, b. 11 Mar 1838, d. 3 Oct 1910, his wife, s/w Austiin Sweet
Sweet, Philothy T, d. 28 Apr 1879, age: 72y 9m 28d, wife of Benj
Sweet, Susannah, d. 7 Mar 1880, age: 47y 2m 24d, wife od E.D. Sweet
Teague, Mable H, b. 22 Feb 1898, d. 17 Aug 1902, adopted daughter of J.N. and H.J. Cobb
Unversaw, Mary M, d. 14 Feb 1891, age: 11y 1m 14d
Vincent, Dudley, b. 1828, d.
Vincent, John J, d. 28 Nov 1885, age: 64y 11m 21d
Vincent, Nancy, b., d. 12 Apr 1886, age: 87y 4m 28d
Ward, Frank M, b. 6 Oct 1861, d. 3 Oct 1908
Ward, Sarah Ann, b. 1835, d. 1920, wife of Legrand Ward, Mother
Ward, Yoma, d. 21 Jan 1887, age: 18y 7m 12d, Wife of Frank Ward, s/w Frank Ward
Ward, infant, d. 21 Jan 1887, s/w Frank Ward
Warren, Jose, b. 1876, d. 1937, Plate set in stone has the inscrption, "John Cobb racing special 394 miles an hr. 1947 and shows a race car"
Warren, Josephine, b. 1877, d. 1938
Warren, infant, d. 1911, infant daughter of J.A. and J Warren
Warren, infant, d. 1912, infant son of J.A. and J Warren
West, Van B, b. 1857, d. 1934
Wilson, Ellan, d. 21 Dec 1861, age: 2y 2m 3d, Daugher of T and S.A. Wilson
Wilson, Evaline, d. 14 Mar 1855, age: 30y 7m 14d, Wife of Thomas Wilson
Wilson, Joel, b. 22 Apr 1798, d. 31 Jul 1846
Wilson, Mahala J, d. 22 Dec 1860, age: 29y 1m 20d, Wife of Franklin Wilson
Wilson, Mary, b. 7 Jun 1790, d. 6 Feb 1882, Wife, s/w Joel Wilson
Wilson, infant, d. 12 Mar 1864, Son of T. and S.A. Wilson
Wise, James H, b. 29 Nov 1879, d. 2 Feb 1897, son of Howard and H Wise
Woods, Fred M, b. 1882, d. 1941

Misc:
Culmer,, no dates
Cobb, infant son, no dates