Search New York Death Records

•  New York Newspapers, Full Search (1730-2018), 1,027 titles
•  New York Obituary Search - (1870-current)
•  New York Birth Records Database, (1767-1999)

Shelter Island Presbyterian Cemetery
Shelter Island, Suffolk County, New York

GPS: 41.068798, -72.337369

32 N. Ferry Rd.
Shelter Island, NY 11964

Total records: 42

This cemetery is located off the main road in Shelter Island, which is still only accessable by ferry. Shelter Island sits off the coast of Greenport NY, between the north and south forks of LI way out on the tip of the island.

This is not a complete listing of burials! The records below were provided by contributors to Cemetery Records Online.

Contributor's Index:

• [SW] Susan Winters [flsu40@aol.com]

Cartwright, Terrie, b. Dec 25, 1841, d. Oce 21, 1905 w/o Charles M, [SW]
Clark, Chancy A, d. Oct 1, 1895 age 60, [SW]
Clark, Elizabeth S Havens, b. 1842, d. 1919, w/o Samuel C, [SW]
Clark, Samuel C, d. Jun 18, 1875 age 72 h/o Hannah young, [SW]
Clark, Samuel C., b. 1839, d. 1906, [SW]
Congdon, Abigail Dockray, d. Jul 25, 1841 age 31 (2nd w/o Calvin M.Griffing), [SW]
Congdon, Amanda A, b. Jan 25, 1824, d. Aug 24, 1899, [SW]
Congdon, Timothy, b. May 20, 1815, d. Jan 6, 1888, [SW]
Crook, Samuel, d. May 20, 1838 age 71 yrs, 5 mo, 23 d., [SW]
Crook, Sylvestor J, d. Mar 1852 at Hong Kong age 25 yrs 6 mo (in memory of), [SW]
Curtis, Mary Gardiner, b. Plymouth MA, Jul 5, 1879, d. New York city May 11, 1961 (widow of Frederick Prime), [SW]
Dennis, Darius, b. Jun 24, 1833, d. Nov 6, 1892 (Our Father-Blessed are they that die in the Lord), [SW]
Dennis, Francis Elizabeth Griffing, b. May 12, 1834, d. Aug 12, 1905, w/o Darius Dennis (Our Mother-A good wife, mother, christian), [SW]
Dickerson, Louisa B Simpson, b. 1834, d. 1914, w/o Nathan P., [SW]
Dickerson, Nathan P, b. 1830, d. 1894, [SW]
Downs, James L, b. b. 1852, d. 1925 h/o Mary T, [SW]
Downs, Mary T, b. 1860, d. 1905 w/o James L, [SW]
Duvall, Thomas M, b. Mar 26, 1826, d. Mar 31, 1870, h/o Asenath Griffing, [SW]
Edwards, Clara (Jouvet), b. 1877, d. 1924, w/o Capt Roy, [SW]
Edwards, Clara (Jouvet), b. 1877, w/o Capt Roy, [SW]
Griffing, Absalom S., d. June 21, 1876 age 46 yrs-3 mo, [SW]
Griffing, Asenath, b. Oct 29, 1823, d. Sep 27, 1898, [SW]
Griffing, Asneath Conklin, b. Jul 16, 1789, d. Jul 23, 1805 w/o Moses D, [SW]
Griffing, Benamin E., b. 1903, d. 1919, [SW]
Griffing, Calvin M, d. Dec 24, 1871 age 73, [SW]
Griffing, Capt Roy M, b. 1874, d. 1938, [SW]
Griffing, Charles M, b. Mar 20, 1833, d. Jan 16, 1917, [SW]
Griffing, Fanny, d. Jul 14, 1885 age 58 yrs-1 mo, w/o Absalom and d/o the late L.V.B and M.R.Woodruff, [SW]
Griffing, Floyd C., b. 1880, d. 1968 s/o Charles M and Terrie, [SW]
Griffing, Isabella, b. Sep 30, 1828, d. Mar 13, 1858, [SW]
Griffing, Jemmia Duvall, d. 1877 age 78 (3rd w/o Calvin M Griffing), [SW]
Griffing, Leroy O, b. 1900, d. 1905, [SW]
Griffing, Moses D.,, d. Sep 26, 1835 age 77, [SW]
Hance, Theodore Crane, b. Mar 20, 1843, d. Mar 10, 1920, [SW]
Scott, David E., b. 1882, d. 1882, [SW]
Scott, Effie M.C., b. 1857, d. 1938, [SW]
Scott, Verner B, b. 1885, d. 1886, [SW]
Scott, Vivien C, b. Apr 27, 1884, d. Mar 22, 1917, [SW]
Simpson, Eliza, b. 1841, d. 1881, sister of Louisa B Dickerson, Mary J. d/o Nathan P and Susan, d. Jan 4, 1816 age 11 yrs 9 mo 8 dy, We trust she is an angel now, In you abodes of bliss, Who would call her back again, To such a world as this, [SW]
Sylvestor, Brinley Esq'r, d. Dec 24, 1752 age 59 this is an old "table" style long, flat, raised Marker. There is beautiful artwork and says "Here lies interr'd the Remains of Brinley Sylvestor Esq'r who departed this life Dec the 24th, 1752 in the 59th year of his age" I have a photo of this Marker if anyone is interested., [SW]
Tuthill, Nancy Howse, b. Feb 28, 1852, d. Dec 15, 1929, [SW]
Young, Hannah, d. Oct 12, 1888 age 83 w/o of Samuel C Clark b 1875, [SW]